Screencasting tools comparison

The TeleCampus Course Development Team at the University of Texas recently completed a side-by-side comparison of the major screencasting tools.  Look across the top of the page for the links to demos of Captivate, ViewletBuilder/ViewletCam, and Camtasia.  Last "tab" is a comparison, which I found a little confusing.  There are numbers running down the left side that don’t have a key.  At first I thought they were the number of products that could do X in the grid, but that didn’t seem to match up.  The MS Word version is a little easier to read.  While I only skimmed the grid, I noticed some of the information to be suspect (for instance, they indicate ViewletBuilder isn’t available for the Mac – oh wait, the Mac version appears to have been pulled from the Qarbon site!).  Ok, the only other thing I noticed then was that their prices seemed a little high – I don’t think the prices on their grid represent educational discounts for Camtasia or ViewletBuilder.  They also don’t tell us specifically which versions of the software they were using (Camtasia recently released a new version, for instance).  I found it ironic that the Macromedia product seemed to do the worst job of capturing a flash file!

Thanks to Karen in Winnipeg for the link.


Comments

One response to “Screencasting tools comparison”

  1. Maybe good additions to this post are the checklist of criteria for selecting a screencasting tool at http://www.indoition.com/screencasting-tool-choosing.htm, as well as the list of screencasting tools at http://www.indoition.com/screencasting-tools-survey.htm.